
Noble Knight Games: Where to Buy, Sell, and Trade New and Used Games
Noble Knight Games is a Wisconsin-based tabletop game retailer where you can buy new, used, and out-of-print games, and where you can also sell or trade your own games for cash or store credit. It has been in business since 1997, ships worldwide, and is a legitimate company with a real warehouse, a published grading system, and a strong record on marketplaces like eBay. If you are hunting for a hard-to-find board game, RPG book, or miniature, or you want to clear a shelf of games you no longer play, it is one of the most practical places to start.
This guide covers how the store works in practice: what it sells, how its condition grades read, how selling and trading work, what shipping and returns look like, and how it compares with eBay and Amazon. The details come from Noble Knight’s own policy pages, its seller profiles, and customer review sites, checked in late October 2026. Prices, shipping rates, and policies do change, so confirm anything important at checkout or on the company’s help pages before you spend or ship.
What is Noble Knight Games?
Noble Knight Games started in 1997 as a hobby. Aaron Leeder, then working at a General Motors plant in Janesville, Wisconsin, spent his spare time tracking down books and games that were going out of print, and he listed what he found on a small website called Aaron’s Out of Print Games. The name changed over the years, but the idea behind it did not: buy, sell, and trade hard-to-find games, and describe their condition honestly.
Today the company works from a purpose-built headquarters at 2835 Commerce Park Drive in Fitchburg, Wisconsin, a few minutes from downtown Madison. The building holds the warehouse, the retail store, and a play area. Noble Knight says it employs more than 100 people and keeps over 300,000 items in stock.
One detail sets it apart from many online sellers. The company says it has no phantom inventory, which means that if a game shows as in stock, a copy is sitting on a shelf in Fitchburg and ready to ship. You are not paying a drop-shipper who hopes to find the item afterward.
If you live near Madison, you can browse the shelves and join the events and tournaments held at the gaming tables. Everyone else shops through the website, which also offers storefronts priced in Australian dollars, Canadian dollars, euros, British pounds, and Japanese yen.
What Can You Buy at Noble Knight Games?
Almost anything tied to tabletop gaming, from this month’s releases to games that went out of print decades ago. Role-playing games are a large part of the catalog, including Dungeons & Dragons, Pathfinder, World of Darkness, Call of Cthulhu, Shadowrun, and TSR-era modules from the 1970s through the 1990s. Beyond RPGs, you will find board games, war games, miniatures and miniature games such as Warhammer, historical miniatures, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and other collectible card games. The store also carries dice, card sleeves, paints, playmats, novels, comics, magazines, video games, movies, art prints, and gift cards.
Out-of-print games are the real draw. Much of the used stock comes from the store’s own trade-in program, so new arrivals appear on the site every day. Kickstarter exclusives, limited editions, and deluxe versions turn up too, and each listing notes any exclusive content.
Listings are specific about printings, which helps collectors. Take Twixt, the 1962 connection game that 3M sold in its bookshelf series. Noble Knight lists the 3M Red Edition as its own entry and adds a link to other printings and editions, so anyone chasing a Twixt (tan edition) at Noble Knight Games can follow that link instead of guessing. On the modern side, Ora & Labora (3rd Edition) is the 2020 Lookout Games printing of Uwe Rosenberg’s monastery-building game, listed for one to four players and a playing time of 60 to 180 minutes. A search for ora & labora at Noble Knight Games shows the edition, price, and stock status on one page.
Smaller titles are covered as well. Uluk, a one-hour Euro game for one to four players, appears as the Wrath of the Gods expansion, and the listing states plainly that it is not standalone. If you want Uluk at Noble Knight Games, you need the base game too. Cannon Buster is a light 2017 pirate game for two to four players that runs about 30 minutes, and a quick search for Noble Knight Games Cannon Buster will tell you whether a copy is on the shelf right now.
If a game’s looks matter to you as much as its rules, the Vintage Bookshelf line is worth a glance. The noble knight games vintage bookshelf edition of Chess, for example, packs the game into a fabric-wrapped box that looks like a hardcover book and sits comfortably on a bookcase.
How to Buy Games From Noble Knight Games
Start with the category menus at the top of the site, such as RPGs, board games, war games, minis, Magic and CCGs, and dice and supplies, or use the search box. Each listing shows the publisher, edition, publication year, player count, game length, and a stock status like In-Stock or Ready to Ship. Used copies carry a condition grade. Reduced items are tagged Price Reduced beside the original list price, and sold-out items show when they were last in stock.
Search the way the site writes titles. Editions go in brackets, as in Battlelore (2nd Edition) or Summoner Wars – Master Set (2nd Edition), so if you want a specific printing, such as TUF (2nd Edition) at Noble Knight Games, include the edition label. Titles that begin with The or A are often filed with the article at the end, like BoardGameGeek Game, The. That means a search for the record game, The, at Noble Knight Games is easier if you type Record Game, The.
When you are ready, add items to your cart and check out. The cart adjusts on its own if someone buys the last copy while you are deciding. Payment options include major credit cards and PayPal, and gift cards are sold too. Orders usually ship within 24 hours on weekdays, and you can follow yours under My Account, then Order History. If you need to change or cancel an order, email contact@nobleknight.com quickly, because changes are often impossible once an order is marked ready to mail or shipped.
A few features reward patience. The Want List emails you when an item you are after comes in, the weekly newsletter lists new inventory, and the store takes special orders for in-print items through its distribution partners. Pre-orders are available for upcoming releases, and you can cancel one for a refund before it ships.
Most product pages also include a chat helper called the Helpful Squire. The site labels it an AI assistant and tells you to verify its answers, which is sound advice. For anything that affects your money, such as whether a used game is complete, ask the team by email.
Understanding Noble Knight Games’ Used Item Grading System
Condition is where Noble Knight has built most of its reputation. Every used item is checked by hand by the cataloging team in Fitchburg, graded, and bagged individually, so the condition on the listing is meant to be the condition that arrives. The rule is blunt: if the team is unsure whether an item earns a grade, it gets the lower one.
Grades run from Shrink Wrapped and Mint at the top, through Near Mint, Excellent, and Very Good, down to Fair. A plus sign marks an item close to the next grade up, and a minus sign marks one leaning toward the grade below. EX+, for instance, sits between Excellent and Near Mint.
Shrink Wrapped and Mint Conditions
Shrink Wrapped (SW) means the item is still in its original factory shrink wrap. The grade of what is inside is noted in brackets, so SW (NM) is a sealed copy in near-mint condition. Mint (M) means perfect, brand new. New stock sold by the store is factory sealed or fresh from the publisher, so these two grades matter most when you are buying a sealed older game, where the shrink wrap itself may show its age.
Near Mint (NM) and Excellent (EX)
Near Mint is like new with only the slightest wear, and it is often hard to tell from Mint. Excellent is lightly used but almost like new. It may have very small spine creases or slight corner wear, but no tears and no marks. Board and war games in these grades show little to no wear and are considered punched unless the note says unpunched. Collectors who care about condition usually shop in this range.
Very Good (VG) and Fair Conditions
Very Good is a used grade. Expect medium creases, corner dings, minor tears or scuffs, or small stains, but the item is complete and fully usable. Fair is very well used. It is still complete and playable, yet it can have tears, pen marks or highlighting, large creases, and stains. If you want to play or run a game rather than display it, VG is often the sweet spot, because a Very Good copy of an out-of-print RPG book reads exactly like a pristine one and costs less.
How to Evaluate Box Condition and Game Components
Boxed items are graded with two codes separated by a slash, such as VG/NM. The first code describes the box and the second describes the contents. A single code means both are in the same condition. Beyond the grade, read the notes, because major defects and missing components are listed separately.
A few conventions are worth knowing. Board game counters are punched unless the listing says otherwise, and if a game with loose counters turns out to be unplayable, it can be returned for a refund. Boxed games and box sets usually do not come with dice. The cardboard backing on miniature packs is not graded, but if it is badly worn, the listing says card worn. Books can carry a remainder mark, usually a small black line or dot in felt-tip pen on the page edges, which publishers add when unsold copies are returned.
Tips for Choosing the Right Condition Before Buying
Decide first whether you are a player or a collector. Players can save money with VG or even Fair copies, while collectors should look at SW, NM, and EX. Read the condition note, not just the letters, since the note is where missing pieces, worn trays, and marks are spelled out. Check whether an item is an expansion that needs a base game, like the Uluk expansion mentioned earlier. And if one detail decides your purchase, such as whether a particular card sheet is included, email the team at contact@nobleknight.com before you order.
How to Sell Your Games to Noble Knight Games
Selling to Noble Knight starts with a list. Email it to trades@nobleknight.com or use the form on the Sell/Trade page. You can type the items into the email, attach a document or spreadsheet up to 8 MB, or use the store’s list templates. Include everything that came with each item and note any missing parts, writing, or heavy wear. Games should be free of water, smoke, and mold damage. The store also buys loose dice and miniatures without their packaging, and it says it does not cherry-pick the best items from a collection.
Within a few business days,s you get a quote based on current demand and condition. It shows what you would earn in cash, in store credit, or in both. If you accept, ask for shipping labels. Noble Knight emails you FedEx labels and pays the shipping when you follow its packing guidelines. Boxes should be sturdy, taped on every open edge, no larger than 18 by 15 by 18 inches, and under 40 pounds. FedEx can even pick the boxes up for free if you call and ask for a ground return pickup. If you live close enough, you can drop everything off at the Fitchburg store instead.
Once the boxes arrive, the team usually processes them within one to two business days, though holidays and very large shipments can stretch that to about a week. Cash goes out by PayPal or business check. People outside the United States should email first to check how shipping works for their country.
One honest note on payouts. A store has to resell what it buys, so an offer will usually come in below what a patient seller might get from a private buyer. Customer reviews reflect that split. Some sellers describe offers that beat their expectations, and at least one reviewer called a large-bundle offer a lowball. The quote costs you nothing, so request it, compare it with a second option, and decide from there.
How Does the Noble Knight Games Trade Program Work?
Trading follows the same intake process as selling. The only difference is the payout: instead of cash, you take store credit and spend it on other games.
Step-by-Step Guide to Trading Your Games
- List what you want to trade, with condition notes and anything missing.
- Send the list to trades@nobleknight.com or through the online form.
- Review the quote and choose store credit for all or part of the payment.
- Request free FedEx labels, pack the games following the guidelines, and ship them, or bring them to the Fitchburg store.
- Wait for inspection, which typically takes one to two business days after arrival.
- Log in to your account to see the credit, which is ready to use right away and applies automatically at checkout.
What Items Are Eligible for Trade?
The store buys and trades role-playing games, board games, war games, miniatures, books, dice, cards, comics, novels, collectibles, and rare or obscure items. Its own description is nearly anything related to games or geek culture. Collections of every size are welcome, from one item to a whole library, and the store says it will look at incomplete items, so describe what is missing rather than hide it. Very large lots take longer to process, so email the trades team first, especially if you plan to come to the store in person.
Benefits of Trading Games for Store Credit
The main benefit is value. The store says its credit offer is always higher than its cash offer, and it adds bonus trade-in value when you choose credit for all or part of your payment. Credit never expires, works on anything in the catalog online or in the store, and can even go toward shipping. The free USA shipping on orders over $149 still applies when you pay with credit. For anyone who already shops there, trading is a way to turn games that sit unused into the next purchase without spending cash.
Tips for Getting the Best Value From Your Collection
Keep sets together and complete, because missing pieces lower value. Separate and label special extras such as Kickstarter bonuses, promos, exclusives, and expansion decks, since the store says these can raise a trade’s value. Pack tightly with padding around any edge that touches the box, so items arrive in the condition you described. Use the store’s list templates to speed up the quote, and avoid sending a pile of small boxes, which can arrive separately. Check the Knight’s Most Wanted Buylist for titles the store is actively looking for. Skip the busiest holiday weeks if you can, and call ahead to book a time for large in-person trades.
Noble Knight Games Shipping, Returns, and Customer Support
Shipping Options Within the USA
Orders placed on weekdays usually ship within 24 hours, and many ship the same day if placed in the morning. Standard economy shipping is free on orders of $149 or more. Below that, flat-rate shipping never exceeds $9.95, no matter how much you order. Economy typically arrives in two to seven days, though some locations can take up to 21. Faster choices include FedEx at about two to five business days, with tracking and insurance included, and overnight express. FedEx Ground does not deliver to P.O. boxes. If you live near Fitchburg, in-store pickup is free, and Wisconsin orders include sales tax.
International Shipping for Global Customers
Noble Knight ships internationally every day, and more than 99% of its inventory is eligible. Flat-rate shipping is capped at $19.95 for Canada, $24.95 for the United Kingdom, $34.95 for the European Union, and $59.95 for Australia, Japan, and New Zealand. Other destinations are calculated at checkout. Carrier options include FedEx International Connect Plus, which the store lists at three to seven business days after customs clearance, DHL Express at two to five business days, and several USPS services. Customs duties and import taxes depend on your country, so read the international customers page before ordering. Treat the caps above as a guide and use the shipping calculator, since checkout has the final word.
Return and Refund Policies
The store accepts returns within 30 days of purchase, on both defective and non-defective items, new or used. After 30 days, it says it will still consider requests case by case, and it also offers exchanges. To start, email contact@nobleknight.com or visit the store. For defective items, Noble Knight covers return shipping. For non-defective items, return shipping is on you, and the item must be in its original condition. There are no restocking fees, and refunds are typically processed within three to five business days of the store receiving the return. Pre-orders can be canceled for a refund before they ship.
How to Contact Customer Support
The quickest route is email at contact@nobleknight.com, and selling questions go to trades@nobleknight.com. You can also call (608) 758-9901, use the Contact page, or browse the help center, which covers ordering, payment, privacy, and grading. The store’s eBay profile shows a typical reply time of about 24 hours.
What to Do If an Order Arrives Damaged or Incomplete
Check your order as soon as it arrives. If a box is crushed, an item is damaged, or something is missing, take clear photos of the outer box, the packing, and the item, then email contact@nobleknight.com with your order number and a short description. Noble Knight says that if an item does not match its listed condition, it will make it right. For missing components in a used board game, the team says it will either supply the missing pieces or resolve the issue another way, and a game with loose counters that turns out to be unplayable can be returned for a refund. Keep the packaging until the matter is settled, and reach out within the 30-day return window.

Is Noble Knight Games Legit and Safe to Use?
Yes, Noble Knight Games is legitimate, and the evidence is easy to check. The company has operated since 1997 and publishes a physical address and phone number in Fitchburg, Wisconsin. It is listed with the Better Business Bureau as an accredited business with an A-range rating. On eBay, it has been a seller since October 1997, with feedback above 99% positive across well over a million items sold. On Trustpilot, roughly 140 reviews lean strongly positive, and the company replies to many of them. Checkout is encrypted, and the store says it does not sell or share customer information.
It isn’t flawless. Some reviewers on ResellerRatings have reported orders that did not match what they ordered, and sellers are split on how fair the buying offers feel. Those complaints are worth knowing about, but they sit alongside a steady pattern of fast shipping, careful packing, and quick fixes when something goes wrong.
A few habits keep you safe. Pay with a credit card or PayPal, so you have a dispute option. Type nobleknight.com yourself instead of following an ad, and note that the official regional storefronts sit under that domain, for example uk.nobleknight.com and ca.nobleknight.com. Be cautious with any site that copies the name but shows no address, no policies, and no history.
Noble Knight Games vs. Other Online Game Stores
Noble Knight is not the only place to buy or sell used games, so here is how it compares with the usual alternatives.
Noble Knight Games vs. eBay
eBay is an open marketplace. Millions of sellers list there, so the choice is huge, but condition descriptions and packing standards vary from seller to seller. Noble Knight sells on eBay too, under the same name and with a decades-long record, so you can often compare the same item in both places. For buyers, the store’s own site offers a consistent grading scale and one set of return rules. For sellers, eBay can bring a higher price on in-demand games, but you take on listing, photos, packing, shipping, buyer questions, and fees. One 2026 seller guide put eBay’s cut around 13.6% plus 40 cents per order in the toys and hobbies category, and rates change. Selling to Noble Knight trades some of that upside for convenience.
Noble Knight Games vs. Amazon
Amazon is strongest for current releases from big publishers, with quick delivery and easy returns. It is weaker for out-of-print games, graded collectibles, and older RPG books, where used copies come from third-party sellers who set their own standards. It is also a different kind of platform for selling. You would set up as a marketplace seller and handle each sale yourself, rather than sending a list and getting a quote for a whole collection.
Noble Knight Games vs. Other Specialty Game Retailers
Local game stores offer community, demos, and play space, and some buy used games, though their shelves are small next to a warehouse of 300,000 items. BoardGameGeek’s marketplace and Reddit’s board game exchange groups suit collectors who want to deal directly, usually without platform fees, but you handle pricing, shipping, and trust yourself, and buyers there often expect a discount. Many online retailers focus mainly on current releases. Noble Knight’s edge is depth in used and out-of-print stock, plus the grading system and the buy-sell-trade program under one roof.
Which Platform Is Better for Buying and Selling Used Games?
It depends on what you value. For buying used and out-of-print games with clear condition notes, Noble Knight is hard to beat. For selling, it is the easiest route, while eBay or a collector community can pay more if you are willing to do the work. Amazon fits best when you want a current game fast.
| Noble Knight Games | eBay | Amazon | |
| Best for | Used and out-of-print games in graded condition | Rare items and the highest possible price | Current releases and quick delivery |
| Effort to sell | Low: email a list, use free shipping labels | High: photos, listings, packing, disputes | Moderate to high: marketplace seller account |
| Typical payout | Below top resale, higher if you take credit | Often highest on in-demand games, minus fees | Varies by seller and category |
| Buyer protection | 30-day returns and a condition promise | eBay Money Back Guarantee | Amazon marketplace policies |
Tips for Getting the Most Out of Noble Knight Games
Set up a Want List for any game you cannot find. New items arrive daily, so an alert beats checking back by hand, and the Recent Arrivals pages are worth a look once a week if you collect. Combine orders to pass the $149 mark for free USA shipping, and remember that store credit can pay toward shipping too. Compare grades before price, because an EX copy at a small premium is often a better buy than a VG copy you end up regretting. Watch for Price Reduced tags, which show a drop from the original list price. Join the newsletter for first notice of rare finds, and ask about a special order if a game is still in print. When you sell, request the quote before you pack anything, and keep your own notes on what you sent.
Final Thoughts
Noble Knight Games earns its reputation by doing a few things well. It stocks a deep range of new, used, and out-of-print tabletop games. It grades honestly and explains the grades in plain terms. It ships worldwide at fair rates, and it makes selling or trading simple enough that you can start with a single email. It will not always pay the most for your games, and it is not the cheapest option for every mass-market title, but for hard-to-find games and low-effort clear-outs, it is a dependable choice.
If you want to try it, there are two easy starting points: search for the game you have been hunting, or send a short list of games you no longer play and see what the quote looks like. Either way, check current prices and policies on the official site first, since those are what apply to your order.
FAQs
Is Noble Knight Games a legitimate website?
Yes. It has operated since 1997, lists a physical address and phone number in Fitchburg, Wisconsin, is a BBB-accredited business, and holds feedback above 99% positive on eBay. Like any retailer, it draws occasional complaints, mostly about order mix-ups or low buy offers, so read the policies before you order.
Does Noble Knight Games sell new and used games?
Yes. New items are factory sealed or fresh from publishers, and used items are hand-graded from Shrink Wrapped down to Fair. A large share of the catalog is out of print, which is why collectors use it.
Can I sell my old board games to Noble Knight Games?
Yes. Email a list to trades@nobleknight.com or use the online form. You will get a quote showing cash, store credit, or both, and you can ship the games using free FedEx labels or drop them off at the Fitchburg store.
Does Noble Knight Games buy entire game collections?
Yes. The store accepts anything from a single item to a whole library and says it does not cherry-pick. For very large collections, contact the trades team first, since big lots take longer to process and in-person drop-offs may need an appointment.
Is store credit worth more than cash?
For trade-ins, yes. The store says credit offers are always higher than cash offers, and credit never expires. It is only the better deal if you plan to shop there, though. If you need money in your bank account, take the PayPal or check payout instead.
Does Noble Knight Games ship internationally?
Yes. It ships worldwide every day, and more than 99% of its inventory is eligible. Flat-rate caps apply for Canada (19.95),theUnitedKingdom(24.95) and the European Union (34.95),andAustralia,Japan,andNewZealand(59.95). Other destinations are calculated at checkout.
How does Noble Knight Games grade used products?
A team in Fitchburg inspects each item by hand and assigns a grade: Shrink Wrapped, Mint, Near Mint, Excellent, Very Good, or Fair, with plus and minus signs for in-between cases. Boxed items get two codes, one for the box and one for the contents, and missing parts are noted separately.
What is the return policy at Noble Knight Games?
Returns are accepted within 30 days of purchase for defective and non-defective items, new or used. The store covers return shipping for defective items, charges no restocking fees, and typically refunds within three to five business days of receiving the return. Email contact@nobleknight.com to start.



